The silent scream of the figure in Francis Bacon’s Figure with Meat echoes in the mind of photographer, chef, and artist, Marshall To, whose childhood inclined him to pay attention to the spiritual and mysterious. In creating his photobook, Blank Notes, published by Charcoal Press, he blurs the divide between what we believe to be reality and the supernatural in black and white images that submerge us into a calm, but at times chilling world.
He sets out to capture the Hungry Ghosts from Taoist tradition where the gates of Hell open letting out spirits in the form of owls, wolves, birds, and even attractive humans who prowl the Earth for nourishment. To’s use of light and movement bends our perceptions of the world and offer a glimpse into a realm unbeknownst to us, pushing the audience to consider there may be something bigger than ourselves.
Blank Notes is a love letter to his heritage and to first- and second-generation immigrants who he says combine older worlds with the modern to forge new stories and realities. As children of immigrants, we have a learned habit of disentangling our identities and placing them into two or three separate boxes for easy legibility, instead of leaving the tangles and embracing complication. To reflects this in his work by chipping away at the confinement of his identity and spirituality.
Portrait-Marshall-To.jpg
You started out working as a chef and your parents also owned a Chinese restaurant. How important was food in your personal life growing up and into adulthood?
It was everything to me from the get-go; it was my first introduction to my own culture in a place where there were very few Chinese people. It taught me that food can bring people together no matter their beliefs and differences. It was also the only way some people knew how to show their love and now, for better or for worse, I started doing the same thing. Words can sometimes be very difficult to say when you’re not used to saying them but it’s easy for me to cook you whatever you want and show you how much I care.
It’s interesting to me that you began your career working as a chef because the sensory experience of cooking and photography is quite different. The display of food and the presentation of photos appeal to a similar notion of aesthetic, but the way one consumes each medium diverges. What about being a chef and working with food made you move to photography?
Early on in my cooking career, I began doing food photography at the same time. It made me look at light differently than I ever did before — good light, bad light, etc. I really enjoyed styling and creating a whole scene with food but it started to feel hollow, it was missing a sort of chase. I wanted to feel butterflies, so I chased the first thing I ever loved and that was animals. It was also then that I realised that I was more of an artist than I was a chef. I needed to create physically and intimately with food or illustrations and simultaneously taking photos which then satiated my visual hunger with more immediacy.
In Blank Notes, you explore the celebration of the Hungry Ghosts in Taoist tradition. You yourself grew up in a small town in Canada while also being part of an immigrant household practicing Taoism. How is the diasporic identity weaved into your photography?
First- or second-generation immigrants are the most unique people I find, almost a perfect combination of different or older worlds colliding with new, and with that comes very specific stories and uniquely relatable ones. As I started to grow into my identity as an artist, I realised that I needed to stop compartmentalising who I was. That being fully myself would make my work inherently unique.
Nature and animals are a large part of your collection and of the Taoist tradition. Did growing up in Canada also inform your fascination with nature?
I grew up in the plains of Alberta. In the summer, it would be hot and dry during the day but thunderous and exciting at night. The winters were sunny and dropped down to minus fifty degrees Celsius, the sky would be blue but the landscape would be blanketed in snow. It made me aware of the force that nature is and the beauty that it creates.
How do you think the coexistence of the natural and the supernatural in Taoist tradition are different from that of Western traditions?
I think that the Western world has moved on so much faster than other cultures. Since modernity it has, understandably so, become increasingly more of a secular society and less interested in the unknown and mysterious. Older traditions seem to have space for mystery and the unknown.
What aspects of Taoism do you carry with you in your daily life? How do they impact you as a person and your work as a photographer?
My parents burn incense on an altar that carries statues of deities and photos of our ancestors every morning and ask them to look over our family. I’ve carried on those rituals more and more as complicated health situations have risen in my family. In times of need, it helps me even if I have one foot in and one foot out half the time. Sometimes it allows me to be more vulnerable because it allows me to believe in something bigger than myself, even just for a second. That impacts me the most as a person foremost and secondly as a photographer. Letting in the pain and heartache to only digest it and create from it.
What made you want to explore this specific Taoist tradition where the gates of Hell open releasing the Hungry Ghosts?
As a child, my parents would tell me to not do anything disrespectful outside of the protection of our house like peeing behind a dumpster or screaming and shouting in the ether, inviting unwanted attention during this festival. I’ve had my own experiences with the supernatural that made me fear these festivals. I wasn’t allowed to get out of the car when we would go visit our ancestors at the cemetery because I would fall ill every time. I stopped believing in all these things for so long as I grew into adulthood, it was in the back of my mind and I was never sure whether it was all real or not. I guess Blank Notes is my way of translating it into something tangible and real.
Blank Notes is shot in black and white film, which forces the audience to focus on the shadows and silhouettes and, in this collection, also invokes mystery. What drew you to this style?
I found that black and white film allowed you to immerse yourself faster in a different world and mindspace. Black and white movies such as Kuroneko and Onibaba really helped me see how those specific stories could be told and allow one to suspend belief.
Photography is a depiction of reality in a sense, capturing what is right in front of you in a seemingly objective way. How do you navigate trying to represent the supernatural in such a physical and tangible medium?
Movement is such a big part of it for me, you can bend the depiction of reality with movement of the subject matter and movements of the camera itself. I honestly just like to have fun with it and experiment and hope for the best. If a rabbit hole presents itself, then I’ll go down it as far as I can. In this case I chose to photograph the things that gave me butterflies, gave me a sense of chase and fear. At times I would go to a park alone at night with all noises with a headlamp afraid of the unseen and attempt to photograph that feeling.
I see you also paint and draw, primarily the human form, in an almost macabre manner. What made you choose this style of painting? How is it also reflected in your photography?
It’s pretty safe to say that I gravitate towards the dark as there is a different kind of beauty there. I remember the first time I saw Francis Bacon’s painting Figure With Meat and it was seared into my brain. I couldn’t stop looking at it because I had never seen anything like it before. I’m not sure exactly that it’s reflected in my photography, but I’m keen to reflect it in my practice in the future as they are both very much in the same breath.
Through the movement in the photos, I feel like I can peer into the divide between the natural and supernatural, as though the movement distorts the subject, possibly giving a glimpse into their demonic side. Why do you think it’s important to portray this thin divide between reality and the other-worldly?
It felt imperative to depict the thin divide, the weaving back and forth of realities because that’s how I imagine that it is, constantly confusing and blurry like a fever dream.
Some of the photos also play with the focus where the subject is blurred or a wash of light obscures the image. To me, it reflects the message of what we can see in our reality and the veil that separates us and the supernatural. Can you tell me a bit about your thinking behind this?
A lot of that came from inspiration of other artists' work such as Trent Parke and Masao Yamamoto, who photograph their environments but make them look supernatural, like a beam of sunlight lighting a single person up like a god in a crowd of people. I tried to find ways myself of photographing the same objects in different ways to create more dualities. When you open up the shutter, you allow the reality in front of you to be distorted.
Who are some of your inspirations in your work?
Where do I start… I guess Masahisa Fukase’s Ravens specifically, which allowed me to see how weaving nature and personal life can be photographed. Jesse Lenz, who mentored me and encouraged me to lean into all this. Igor Posner, Masao Yamamoto, Daido Moriyama, Daisuke Yokota. Painters: Francis Bacon, Jenny Saville, Justin Mortimer. Movies: Kuroneko, The Wailing, Onibaba and those are just some.
Your family was Taoist and you talk about your cultural inspiration from your father’s stories. I’m curious what your family thinks of your photographs?
Most of my family really like the pictures of the owls (laughs). They haven’t really shared what they truly think about my photographs but it’s a book more so dedicated to them than it is for them.
Blank-Notes-01.jpg
From "Blank Notes" by Marshall To, published by Charcoal Press.
Blank-Notes-02.jpg
From "Blank Notes" by Marshall To, published by Charcoal Press.
Blank-Notes-06.jpg
From "Blank Notes" by Marshall To, published by Charcoal Press.
Blank-Notes-07.jpg
From "Blank Notes" by Marshall To, published by Charcoal Press.
Blank-Notes-11.jpg
From "Blank Notes" by Marshall To, published by Charcoal Press.
Blank-Notes-14.jpg
From "Blank Notes" by Marshall To, published by Charcoal Press.
Blank-Notes-15.jpg
From "Blank Notes" by Marshall To, published by Charcoal Press.
Blank-Notes-18.jpg
From "Blank Notes" by Marshall To, published by Charcoal Press.